THE MIND OF THE POOR: A Post Election Analysis

SHARE THE TRUTH

 241 total views

By: Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual
Caritas Manila, Executive Director

Former Senator Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr., the son and appellation of the late President Ferdinand Marcos Sr.,won our nation’s presidency by a landslide, in a remarkable reversal of fortunes for a political dynasty that 36 years ago was overthrown by the “People Power” revolution. Marcos Jr. secured around 60% of the vote in the 2022 national polls, giving him the stoutest mandate for president since his father’s rule. So, the question in everybody’s mind lingers — why did the poor (according to Pulse Asia Class D1 voters are around 8 out of 10 voters in the country) as this country’s majority voters choose Former Senator Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr. to return to power?

By way of qualitative analysis, allow me share with you some insights into the “mind of the poor” vis-à-vis our May 8, 2022 Synchronized National and Elections. Here are the top 5 PSYCHE of the POOR which I have experienced in the course of my apostolate as an active Civil Society Advocate involved in the Cooperative and NGO sector:

 

MINDSET 1: WE NEED A STRONG LEADER TO BRING US TO THE “PROMISE LAND”.

Many “authoritarian populist” leaders outside the West — from Rodrigo Duterte in the Philippines to Vladimir Putin in Russia to Narendra Modi in India — create their social acceptability neither from monetary promises nor from social conservativism alone, but also from a third commitment: to restore public order and state authority without the layers of bureaucracy.

According to Roberto Stefan Foa, “If we are to understand why authoritarian strongmen have won elections in so many developing democracies, we also need to acknowledge the void that such leaders claim to fill — namely, the erosion of political authority. In many such societies, corruption, criminality, and violence not only are pervasive, but have worsened over time, granting the ‘law and order’ pitch of leaders such as Duterte in the Philippines, Modi in India, or Brazil’s Jair Bolsonaro a reach that goes well beyond mere cultural conservatives. In particular, their platforms typically resonate with a section of the new urban middle class that is self-made and upwardly mobile, situated outside the existing network of patronage politics, and frustrated at the persistence of urban crime, inefficient public services, and widespread clientelism and graft.” Thus, the imagery of the former strongman Ferdinand Marcos Sr. now personified by his son, appealed more than the promises of Liberal Democracy campaigned by his staunch rivals.

This is why between seven and eight out of ten Filipinos continue to support Duterte’s brutal “war on drugs” despite its heavy toll in lives lost and rights violated (cf. Samantha Raphelson,“Philippines’ Rodrigo Duterte Sustains Support for Deadly War on Drugs,” National Public Radio, 13 November 2017). A desire for authoritarian leaders in a state that is failing to contain corruption, conflict, or criminality will take on these attributes as its own in the minds of the poor. Moreover, the problem of “excessive bureaucracy” has disheartened the poor that they have become more pessimistic about the value of democracy as a political system, less optimistic
(1) Poor (less than official poverty threshold) Less than PHP 9,100. Low income (but not poor) between the poverty line and twice the poverty line Between PHP 9,100 to PHP 18,200 – Indicative Range of Monthly Family Incomes (for a Family Size of 5 members) [cf. Philippine Institute for Development Studies] that anything they do might affect public policy, and more willing to express backing for authoritarian alternatives.

 

MINDSET 2: UNDERDOGS ARE HEROES.

The “underdog effect” can be manifested in many facets of life (e.g. politics, business or other competitive contexts). Malcolm Gladwell, in his book, David and Goliath: Underdogs, misfits, and the art of battling giants, entertains the reader with a number of rare underdog challenges and victories: dyslexics becoming highly successful entrepreneurs; an individual living in extreme poverty during the Depression-era who rose to become a legendary oncologist; an undersized novice girls’ basketball team succeeding through exploitation of opponents’ conventional tactics.

The lessons are that people are able to take reassurance from these individuals (and many others) explained by the “theory of desirable difficulties” (cf. Robert Bjork, 1988). This theory posits that successful individuals need to have those shortcomings because the fight to succeed against seemingly impossible odds is important for growth. This explains the importance for underdog status, but it does not account for why underdogs hold such a favorable appeal.

So, what made Former Senator Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr. an underdog in a campaign which obviously had the backing of the Duterte administration? Well, Marcos Jr became the most controversial candidate from his non-appearance in various Presidential Debates/Forums to his numerous cases, including a conviction over a tax-evasion case. He does not attack other candidates. This non-confrontational strategy has paid off, and handsomely in the image of an underdog. And instead of differentiating themselves by highlighting their record and capabilities, other candidates have engaged in a pack attack to try and take Marcos Jr down. So far, this has backfired towards the perception of truly being the underdog. We are fascinated with underdog fights. They pervade politics, but contemporary cultures have also embraced our fascination and support for underdogs in their own modern form of storytelling. For example, talent shows invite the viewer to become engrossed in an emotional life story of challenges and seemingly under resourced failures, only to then marvel at the perfect performance and ecstatic ovation. The poor supports an underdog like them for an underdog’s victory gives them a sense of hope that they too someday will be victorious as well.

 

MINDSET 3: IMMEDIATE SHORT-TERM RELIEF OUTWEIGHS A PROMISE OF A
FUTURE BENEFIT.

The Philippine Institute for Development Studies (PIDS) issued a study to determine the distribution of wealth in the Philippines. With the poverty line being a household income of P10,481 per month for a family of five, PIDS reported that 22% of Filipino households are presently living below the poverty line. Households earning between P10,481 to P20,962 are considered the low-income class and they constitute 35% of the population. Together, these two classes constitute 57% of the population. This is what French Economist, Thomas Piketty, calls “wealth inequality”. “All across the world, we see social movements demanding more economic justice, and we also see the need to rethink the organization of economic globalization in order to address social and environmental changes … The general problem that we are facing is the following: If we do not open up new perspectives in terms of social progress and economic justice, and if the “neoliberal centrists” keep pretending that there is only one possible economic policy (basically to the benefit of the most affluent), then we run the risk that the political discussion is going to be more and more about identity, which will provide a winning ground for the nationalists and the nativists” (Thomas Piketty).

Even the Holy Father, Pope Francis says that “while the income of a minority is increasing exponentially, that of the majority is crumbling. This imbalance results from ideologies which uphold the absolute autonomy of markets and financial speculation, and thus deny the right of control to States, which are charged with providing for the common good. A new, invisible and at times virtual, tyranny is established, one which unilaterally and irremediably imposes its own laws and rules” (cf. Address to new Vatican Ambassadors, May 16, 2013).

Thus, if Liberal Democracy has created an economic system which has become “OF THE 1%, BY THE 1%, FOR THE 1%2 ” (cf. Joseph E. Stiglitz, Vanity Fair, 2011) this will eventually create a social divide between the poor and the social elites to which the poor would readily gravitate towards the candidate who they feel is pro-poor and could readily give them the immediate financial relief they need and not the mere promise of economic prosperity which for them is too far from their reach due to this existing socio-economic divide created by liberal democracy. “There is a cultural snobbery of the educated, cosmopolitan, urban-dwelling, sophisticated people that make up elites in modern societies, towards people that have less education, that do not live in big cities, that have more traditional social and cultural values. There is a degree of justified resentment at that kind of disregard” (Francis Fukuyama, Identity Politics).

As such, the lofty promises of future economic gain to which the 36 years of the previous prospect of Liberal Democracy has remained as an “impossible dream” leaving the poor with the notion that what they can “get now” would be better than what they can “get later” considering the perceived empty promises of the past. Thus, the well-oiled grassroots political machinery of a BBM-SARAH tandem enabled the realization of this short-term relief for poor voters. And, though vote buying may be the “inherent” course of action to deliver this immediate interim relief, I will not conclude otherwise. But it is noteworthy to stipulate that the Commission on Elections (Comelec) had received some 400 complaints of vote-buying with “supporting evidence” (cf. Robertzon Ramirez and Sheila Crisostomo, The Philippine Star, May 15, 2022) during the recently held polls. Let me emphasize that in a true democracy every citizen has the right to be elected to public office, subject to reasonable restrictions. Vote buying makes it impossible to meet these standards by penalizing potential candidates who are at an economic disadvantage especially minority candidates.

Veritas Editorial

Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual

Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual

President of Radio Veritas

Separation of Church and State

 95,912 total views

 95,912 total views Mga Kapanalig, ginamit na dahilan ni Senador Robin Padilla ang prinsipyo ng separation of church and state upang depensahan ang kontrobersyal na televangelist na si Apollo Quiboloy. Ito ang kanyang dahilan kung bakit pinangunahan niya ang paglalabas ng isang written manifestation bilang pagtutol sa pagpapaaresto sa nagtatag sa grupong Kingdom of Jesus Christ. 

Read More »

Nagbabadyang gun culture?

 113,985 total views

 113,985 total views Mga Kapanalig, pinapayagan nang muli ng Philippine National Police (o PNP) ang pagkakaroon ng mga sibilyan ng semi-automatic rifles. Ito ay matapos amyendahan ng PNP ang implementing rules and regulations ng Republic Act No. 10591 o ang Comprehensive Firearms and Ammunition Act.  Ipinasá noong 2013 ang naturang batas na naglilimita sa pagmamay-ari ng

Read More »

Agrikultura at ekonomiya

 125,234 total views

 125,234 total views Mga Kapanalig, hindi pa man tayo umaabot sa tinatawag na peak o pinakamatinding bahagi ng nagpapatuloy na El Niño, umabot na sa 151.3 milyong piso ang halaga ng pinsalang idinulot nito sa sektor ng agrikultura.  Ito ang pagtataya ng ating Department of Agriculture batay na rin sa datos na libu-libong tonelada ng palay

Read More »

Book Reading

 158,253 total views

 158,253 total views Uso pa ba ang pagbabasa ng libro ngayon, kapanalig? O mas uso pa ang magcellphone maghapon? May survey noong 2017 na nagsasabi na marami pa rin namang mga kabataan, pati mga adults sa ating bansa na nagbabasa pa rin. Ayon sa survey, kada buwan, mga mahigit walong oras ang ginugugol ng mga bata

Read More »

Katiyakan sa pagkain sa panahon ng tagtuyot

 180,621 total views

 180,621 total views Kapanalig, sa panahon ng tagtuyot, nasa likod na ng isipan ng marami nating kababayan ang pag-aalala at nasa dibdib na rin nila ang kabog ng takot. Sasapat kaya ang pagkain ng pamilya ko  ngayong panahon ng tagtuyot? Ang laki ng epekto ng tagtuyot sa bansa. Marami pa ring lugar sa ating bayan ang agrikultural

Read More »

Watch Live

catholink
Shadow
truthshop
Shadow

Related Story

Latest Blog
Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual

Separation of Church and State

 95,913 total views

 95,913 total views Mga Kapanalig, ginamit na dahilan ni Senador Robin Padilla ang prinsipyo ng separation of church and state upang depensahan ang kontrobersyal na televangelist na si Apollo Quiboloy. Ito ang kanyang dahilan kung bakit pinangunahan niya ang paglalabas ng isang written manifestation bilang pagtutol sa pagpapaaresto sa nagtatag sa grupong Kingdom of Jesus Christ. 

Read More »
Latest Blog
Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual

Nagbabadyang gun culture?

 113,986 total views

 113,986 total views Mga Kapanalig, pinapayagan nang muli ng Philippine National Police (o PNP) ang pagkakaroon ng mga sibilyan ng semi-automatic rifles. Ito ay matapos amyendahan ng PNP ang implementing rules and regulations ng Republic Act No. 10591 o ang Comprehensive Firearms and Ammunition Act.  Ipinasá noong 2013 ang naturang batas na naglilimita sa pagmamay-ari ng

Read More »
Latest Blog
Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual

Agrikultura at ekonomiya

 125,235 total views

 125,235 total views Mga Kapanalig, hindi pa man tayo umaabot sa tinatawag na peak o pinakamatinding bahagi ng nagpapatuloy na El Niño, umabot na sa 151.3 milyong piso ang halaga ng pinsalang idinulot nito sa sektor ng agrikultura.  Ito ang pagtataya ng ating Department of Agriculture batay na rin sa datos na libu-libong tonelada ng palay

Read More »
Latest Blog
Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual

Book Reading

 158,254 total views

 158,254 total views Uso pa ba ang pagbabasa ng libro ngayon, kapanalig? O mas uso pa ang magcellphone maghapon? May survey noong 2017 na nagsasabi na marami pa rin namang mga kabataan, pati mga adults sa ating bansa na nagbabasa pa rin. Ayon sa survey, kada buwan, mga mahigit walong oras ang ginugugol ng mga bata

Read More »
Latest Blog
Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual

Katiyakan sa pagkain sa panahon ng tagtuyot

 180,622 total views

 180,622 total views Kapanalig, sa panahon ng tagtuyot, nasa likod na ng isipan ng marami nating kababayan ang pag-aalala at nasa dibdib na rin nila ang kabog ng takot. Sasapat kaya ang pagkain ng pamilya ko  ngayong panahon ng tagtuyot? Ang laki ng epekto ng tagtuyot sa bansa. Marami pa ring lugar sa ating bayan ang agrikultural

Read More »
Latest Blog
Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual

Turismo sa Pilipinas

 108,522 total views

 108,522 total views Kapanalig, summer na naman. Kakambal na ng summer ang turismo sa ating bayan. Sa ganitong panahon hindi lamang ang araw ang hitik na hitik, kundi pati ang industriya ng turismo sa ating bayan. Nito lamang January, tumaas ng mahigit 23% ang bilang ng mga turista sa ating bansa. Mahgit 574,000 tourists ang dumating

Read More »
Latest Blog
Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual

Single parents

 150,764 total views

 150,764 total views Alam mo ba kapanalig, na umaabot sa 15 million ang single parents sa ating bayan? Sa bilang na ito, 95% ay mga babae. Timely, kapanalig, na mapag-usapan natin ito, lalo na at parating na ang kapistahan ni San Jose ngayong Marso 19. At pag usapin ng pagiging ama, si San Jose ang isa

Read More »
Latest Blog
Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual

Street People

 161,881 total views

 161,881 total views Kapanalig, napapansin mo pa ba ang mga taong lansangan na nadadaanan mo araw-araw habang papunta ka sa trabaho o paaralan? Nakikita mo pa ba ang kanilang mga sitwasyon, kondisyon, pati kanilang mukha? Sa mga sidewalks o bangketa, sa tapat ng mga lumang gusali, sa eskinita, makikita natin ang marami nating kapwa Pilipino, kasama

Read More »
Latest Blog
Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual

Internet, Social Media, at Mental Health

 183,953 total views

 183,953 total views Kapanalig, marahil ikaw ay kabilang sa maraming Pilipinong babad na babad sa Internet at social media. Ayon nga sa mga pinakahuling datos, mahigit 85% ng ating populasyon ay internet users, habang 84.45 million   naman ang social media users. Ibig sabihin, halos lahat ng nasa Internet sa atin ay social  media users din. Ang mga

Read More »
Latest Blog
Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual

National Women’s Month

 226,299 total views

 226,299 total views Mga Kapanalig, Happy National Women’s Month!  Sa darating na Biyernes, March 8, ipagdiriwang ang International Women’s Day na may temang “Invest in women: Accelerate progress”. Dito naman sa atin, ang Marso ay National Women’s Month at ang tema ng pagdiriwang nito ay “Lipunang Patas sa Bagong Pilipinas; Kakayahan ng Kababaihan, Patutunayan!”. Layunin ng

Read More »
Latest Blog
Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual

Make polluters pay

 237,364 total views

 237,364 total views Mga Kapanalig, isang taon matapos ang Mindoro oil spill, wala pa ring napananagot sa pinsalang idinulot ng trahedya sa kapaligiran at kabuhayan ng mga apektadong komunidad. Hindi pa rin nakakamit ng mga residente ang katarungan at buong kabayaran para sa nawalang hanapbuhay nila, lalo na noong ipinataw ang limang buwan na fishing ban.

Read More »
Latest Blog
Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual

Katarungan para kay Jemboy

 151,539 total views

 151,539 total views Mga Kapanalig, patuloy na nanawagan ng katarungan ang pamilya ni Jemboy Baltazar, ang 17 anyos na binatang taga-Navotas na binaril ng mga pulis noong Agosto ng nakaraang taon habang naghahanda siya at ang kanyang kaibigang pumalaot para mangisda. Napagkamalan daw sila ng mga pulis na suspek sa kaso ng pagnanakaw. Noong isang linggo,

Read More »
Latest Blog
Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual

Pinupulitikang ayuda

 145,883 total views

 145,883 total views Mga Kapanalig, noong kasagsagan ng pandemya, naging matunog na salita ang “ayuda” o ang pinansyal na tulong na natanggap mula sa pamahalaan ng mga naapektuhan ng malawakang lockdown. Kahit tila balik na tayo sa normal na pamumuhay, nagpatuloy ang pamamahagi ng gobyerno ng ayuda sa ilalim ng iba’t ibang programa nito. Pangunahing benepisyaryo

Read More »
Latest Blog
Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual

Higit sa kita

 156,661 total views

 156,661 total views Mga Kapanalig, “catastrophe” o malaking sakuna ang maaari daw mangyari kapag maisabatas ang panukalang dagdagan ng isandaang piso ang daily minimum wage sa ating bansa.  Iyan ang babala ng isang grupo ng mga negosyante habang kanilang tinututulan ang Senate Bill No. 2354. Ang panukalang batas na ito, na inaprubahan na ng Senado noong

Read More »
Latest Blog
Rev. Fr. Anton CT Pascual

Huwag tayong titiklop, huwag tayong aatras

 162,055 total views

 162,055 total views Mga Kapanalig, ginunita pa rin sana natin kahapon, kahit hindi opisyal na holiday, ang ika-38 taong anibersaryo ng EDSA People Power Revolution.  Marami na sa atin marahil ang nakalimot na o hindi nalalaman ang apat na araw noong Pebrero 1986 kung kailan ipinamalas ng mga Pilipino ang masidhing pagnanais na makaroon ng pagbabago

Read More »

Latest Blogs

Scroll to Top